- Discover essay samples

Uniform Debate

4.9 of 5.0 (191 reviews)

686 words
Social Issues

Uniform Debate Page 1
Uniform Debate Page 2
Uniform Debate Page 3
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

Uniform Debate

The issue of whether or not students should wear uniforms is near and dear to my heart. During my elementary and high school years I attended many schools. Two of the schools were Catholic schools, which required a formal uniform. The Lutheran school I attended had an enforced dress code. There was no dress code at the three public schools I attended.
In 1999, the New York City public school system began enforcing a mandatory uniform policy in its more than 670 elementary schools. (Knowles, 2000) In light of this, I think it is relevant to examine the various arguments presented by both sides in this debate.
In America wearing uniforms in public school got a push from President Clinton in his 1996 State of the Union address. (Evans, 1996) President Clinton believed that wearing uniforms was a necessary step to help decrease violence in our schools. This came in the wake of increasing incidents of student violence and theft because of designer clothing being worn to school.
According to the ?Manual on School Uniforms?, from the United States Department of Education there are five potential benefits of school uniforms. Firstly, they believe that school uniforms will decrease violence and theft. The second potential benefit of school uniforms is that they will prevent gang members from wearing gang colors and insignia. Thirdly, wearing uniforms will instill discipline in students. Fourth, the manual states that wearing uniforms will help parents and students resist peer pressure. Lastly, uniforms help students concentrate on their schoolwork. (Manual on School Uniforms, 2000)
Scientific research regarding these claims is beginning to appear. In ?The Effects of Student Uniforms on Attendance, Behavior Problems, Substance Use, and Academic Achievement? the authors, David Brunsma and Kerry Rockquemore, used data that was obtained from tenth grade students. They used this data to test the claims made by uniform advocates. They found 'student uniforms have no direct effect on substance abuse, behavioral problems or attendance?. (Brunsma and Rockquemore, 1998) In fact, the study found that there was a negative effect on academic achievement when students were forced to wear uniforms. The researchers did find that uniforms fostered academic preparedness, proschool attitudes and peers having proschool attitudes. They concluded 'that uniform policies may indirectly affect school environment and students outcomes by providing a visible and public symbol of commitment to school improvement and reform?. (Brunsma and Rockquemore, 1998)
The previous study supports uniform proponents who argue that wearing school uniforms creates a sense of school spirit. These uniform proponents rationalized that this school spirit will lead to academic pride, which will lead to academic achievements. (Jacobson, 2000) The previous study does not support the second claim.
According to proponents of wearing uniforms, a potential benefit of wearing uniforms is that students are easily identifiable. This easy identification is helpful to teachers during class trips. (Public Debate, 2000) Some people believe that wearing uniforms makes students identifiable, which causes them to act better while coming to and going home from school. (Public Debate, 2000) In addition, intruders in the school building are easily identifiable because they do not wear uniforms. (Forbes, 1994)
Opponents of school uniforms argue that uniforms make student's easily identifiable not just to teachers and security guards but also to students from rival schools. (Public Debate, 2000) They fear that uniforms will emphasize the division between the schools. This in turn may lead to bullying and fights by students from other schools.
Advocates of uniforms claim that another potential benefit of wearing uniforms is that uniforms act as social levelers. (Jacobson, 2000) Proponents of uniforms believe that uniforms help to foster feelings of equality amongst students. For many teens, in order to be cool they must wear the latest fashions. These trendy fashions tend to be costly. Students who are unable to afford the latest fashions are teased. Wearing uniforms take away the peer pressure to own the coolest clothes since everyone is wearing the same clothes.
Opponents of uniforms argue that adopting uniforms does not blur economic lines. Instead wealthier students purchase uniform accessories or wear designer jewelry. Wealthier students will also be ...

You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 686 words of 1371.

Keywords: uniform debate essay, uniform debate against, uniform debate in favour, uniform debate in school, uniform debate pro con, uniforms debate topics, school uniform debate pros and cons, school uniform debate ks2

Similar essays

Teen Pregnancy: Looking On The Dark Side

Katie Story Chapter 1:Article Assignment 2[nd] Statistics Teen Pregnancy: Looking on the dark side When we look around today we see young women, under the age of 18, either are pregnant or have already had their child. It is a young age to start out their child's life when they are hardly an adult themselves, but for some it is a wake-up call to...

94 reviews
Effects of Television Violence on Children

TV Violence: Friend or Enemy? Television violence is a contributing factor to aggressive behavior in children. Recently focus has been placed on this issue, since the majority of violence occurs during prime time and in cartoons. ?It?s not watching that?s bad for kids, it?s what they watch and how much.? (Seplow 2) Parents must a...

212 reviews
Assisted Suicide

It is upsetting and depressing living life in the shadow of death. Many questions appear on this debatable topic, such as should we legalize euthanasia? What is euthanasia? What is assisted suicide? What is Mercy Killing? But if euthanasia was legalized, wouldn?t patients then die peacefully rather than using plastic bags or other...

114 reviews
Sexual Addiction

, can be better defined if compared with other types of addicts. There is little difference between the voyeur waiting for hours by a window for forty seconds of nudity and the compulsive gambler hunching on a long shot. An alcoholic's relationship with alcohol becomes more important than family, friends, and work. The relationship progresses to...

95 reviews
Abortion Pro Choice Opinion

Abortion Pro-Choice Opinion One of the basic questions every society mustface is which areas of behavior to leave to private choice and which to regulate in the interest of public good. It has been already been decided by the Supreme Court in Roe v.s. Wade that ?the fundamental right to privacy protect6ed by the Due Process Clause o...

98 reviews
Is It Wise to Make Friends Online?

Nowadays, with the development of Internet, making friends online is prevalent. Considering safety and personal development, I maintain that making friends online is unreliable and unwise. First of all, it is dangerous for teenagers, who still cannot distinguish wrong and right, to make friends with strangers. Some kidnappers and human trafficke...

197 reviews
Victoria's Secret Vs Gap

There is no doubt that Victoria's Secret has done extremely well in the lingerie market. Gap has established a strong name in the field of clothing in women's and men's casual dress. Gap is now discussing opening what will become GapBody. A branch from their other stores that will carry lingerie, a store similar to that of Victoria's Secret. I...

14 reviews
TV Violence

Since the advent of television, the effect of TV violence on society has been widely studied and vigorously debated. Based on the cumulative evidence of studies conducted over several decades, the scientifi c and public health communities overwhelmingly conclude that viewing violence poses a harmful risk to children. Critics of the research challen...

6 reviews
Gender And Relationship Of Children

By: Your Name Here For: Professor name here Psychology 260.10 Introduction The topic of sex differences in the play preschoolers has been explored by many researchers in the past. Studies have been conducted on basic sex differences such as what toys and gender of playmates do young boys and girls prefer. The size of children's play networks, as...

92 reviews
Hiring Quotas In Employment

Politics is assuming command of the American economy in the form of pervasive "equal opportunity" enforcement. In today's society, everyone is supposed to be equal and have equal rights, but in employment, there is more discrimination than ever. American citizens need to do away with affirmative action so that America's job opportunities can once a...

3 reviews
Managing Waste

, To Save Our World Have you checked your garbage lately? Are you aware that you are throwing away many materials that could be saved? If we did simple things like reusing glass, we could reduce our municipal landfill sites by almost 10%. Waste cannot be simply thrown away anymore, now it must be managed. Managing our trash is the...

56 reviews
Massachusetts Juvenile Justice Reform A Step in the Wrong Direction

Massachusetts Juvenile Justice Reform - A Step in the Wrong Direction THESIS STATEMENT: The Great and General Court of Massachusetts has erred in reforming the juvenile justice system by implementing policies and procedures that will harm juveniles and place society at risk. On July 23, 1995, an intruder brutally attacked and stab...

198 reviews
Freedom and the Constitution

The First Amendment of the United States Constitution protects the right to freedom of religion and freedom of expression from government interference. Freedom of expression is made up of the explicit rights of freedom of speech, press, assembly and to petition the government for a redress of grievances, and the implied right of a...

76 reviews
Early Marriages Are Usually Unhappy Marriages

People who marry at an early age usually have unhappy marriages. The truth can be said for the above statement. The results are sometimes disastrous and painful for some; others seem to never heal emotionally from their experiences. In the community about fifty years ago arranged marriages were acceptable, usually the girls were around twelve to...

74 reviews
Atsisiųsti šį darbą