AskEssays.com - Discover essay samples

The Effects of Race on Sentencing in Capital Punishment Cases

4.9 of 5.0 (1 reviews)

Contains
568 words
Category
Social Issues

The Effects of Race on Sentencing in Capital Punishment Cases Page 1
The Effects of Race on Sentencing in Capital Punishment Cases Page 2
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

The Effects of Race on Sentencing in Capital Punishment Cases




The Effects of Race on Sentencing in Capital Punishment Cases


Throughout history, minorities have been ill-represented in the criminal justice system, particularly in cases where the possible outcome is death. In early America, blacks were lynched for the slightest violation of informal laws and many of these killings occured without any type of due process. As the judicial system has matured, minorities have found better representation but it is not completely unbiased. In the past twenty years strict controls have been implemented but the system still has symptoms of racial bias. This racial bias was first recognized by the Supreme Court in Fruman v. Georgia, 408 U.S. 238 (1972). The Supreme Court Justices decide that the death penalty was being handed out unfairly and according to Gest (1996) the Supreme Court felt the death penalty was being imposed ?freakishly? and ?wantonly? and ?most often on blacks.? Several years later in Gregg v. Georgia, 428 U.S. 153 (1976), the Supreme Court decided, with efficient controls, the death penalty could be used constitutionally. Yet, even with these various controls, the system does not effectively eliminate racial bias.


Since Gregg v. Georgia the total population of all 36 death rows has grown as has the number of judicial controls used by each state. Of the 3,122 people on death row 41% are black while 48% are white (Gest, 1996, 41). This figure may be acceptable at first glance but one must take into account the fact that only 12% of the U.S. population is black (Smolowe, 1991, 68). Carolyn Snurkowski of the Florida attorney generals office believes that the disproportionate number of blacks on death row can be explained by the fact that, ?Many black murders result from barroom brawls that wouldn't call for the death penalty, but many white murders occur on top of another offense, such as robbery? (As cited in Gest, 1986, 25). This may be true but the Washington Legal Foundation offers their own explanation by arguing that ?blacks are arrested for murder at a higher rate than are whites. When arrest totals are factored in , 'the probability of a white murderer ending up on death row is 33 percent greater than in the case of a black murderer? (As cited in Gest, 1986, 25).


According to Professor Steven Goldstein of Florida State University, ?There are so many discretionary stages: whether the prosecutor decides to seek the death penalty, whether the jury recommends it, whether the judge gives it? (As cited in Smolowe, 1991, 68). It is in these discretionary stages that racial biases can infect the system of dealing out death sentences. Smolowe (1991) shows this infection by giving examples of two cases decided in February of 1991, both in Columbus. The first example is a white defendant named James Robert Caldwell who was convicted of stabbing his 10 year old son repeatedly and raping and killing his 12 year old daughter. The second example is of a black man, Jerry Walker, convicted of killing a 22-year-old white man while robbing a convenience-store. Caldwell's trial lasted three times as long as Walker's and Caldwell received a life sentence while Walker received a death sentence. In these examples, it is believed that not only the race of the victims, but also the value of the victims, biased the sentencing decisions. The 22-year-old man killed by Walker was the son of a Army commander at Fort Benning while ...

You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 568 words of 1136.

Similar essays


Crime

in today?s world has become more gruesome with the times. With the crimes comes jail, so more jails are being built for the prisoners. More people are being criminals are being sent to jail and getting the death penalty. Some feel that the death penalty is also a gruesome act of murder. People who commit crimes get what they deser...

96 reviews
Download
How The Simpsons Affects Kids

The Simpsons is one of Americas most popular television shows. It ranks as the number one television program for viewers under eighteen years of age. However, the ideals that The Simpsons conveys are not always wholesome, sometimes not even in good taste. It is inevitable that The Simpsons is affecting children. Matt Groening too...

26 reviews
Download
Public Speaking

Presentation Three Outline BriAna Bond Specific purpose: to persuade my speech class to make sure they have some type of snack during long class hours to keep their energy level up to remain focus during these long class hours. Central idea: Many students spend at least 8 hours a day going to class, but during these 8 hours they go without eatin...

58 reviews
Download
Violence By Children

Violence is a big issue in our society because many people get influenced by it or they recieve it through the television. Childrens minds also have been corrupted by televison because they watch a lot of television while there growing up, so television influences them to act out what they see on television. The main concern with violence is the ch...

80 reviews
Download
Ethics/Child Labor

Today in Minot, ND when you got up, went outside to get the paper, and then sat down and read it as you were getting ready for work, did you ever stop to think how the paper got there. Probably a child delivered it to your door, and he or she gets up early every day before school and delivers it, no matter what the weather is like, seven days a we...

5 reviews
Download
Gay Marriages

A battle has been in progress for years over whether equal rights and equal protection against discrimination should be extended to homosexuals. Recently this has expanded into the area of marriage. The topic of homosexual marriages is a prevalent issue today. Even in the nation?s capital, representatives are finding ways to make t...

83 reviews
Download
Ethics

In today?s world it is all too prevalent to see more and more people hungry to gain success at an ever-increasing rate. Modern culture can and indeed is labelled ?greedy? and ?thoughtless?. Through my relatively short time spent in business, I have encountered many of these types of people. But who are they hungry for? Who benefits...

212 reviews
Download
Sexual Addiction

, can be better defined if compared with other types of addicts. There is little difference between the voyeur waiting for hours by a window for forty seconds of nudity and the compulsive gambler hunching on a long shot. An alcoholic's relationship with alcohol becomes more important than family, friends, and work. The relationship progresses to...

95 reviews
Download
Early Marriages Are Usually Unhappy Marriages

People who marry at an early age usually have unhappy marriages. The truth can be said for the above statement. The results are sometimes disastrous and painful for some; others seem to never heal emotionally from their experiences. In the community about fifty years ago arranged marriages were acceptable, usually the girls were around twelve to...

74 reviews
Download
The Struggle Between Being And Knowing

The reasons we undertake higher education can seem obvious on the surface but I believe that there is much more to consider than initially meets the eye. What are we really seeking? Before we cut the check and dedicate the hours we should ask ourselves what our final objective might be. Is it simply the required degree which allows us a label nex...

82 reviews
Download
Child Abuse; A Social Problem

Imagine for one moment that you are not yourself any longer. Visualize instead that you are a young girl; old enough to know right from wrong yet still young enough to be terrified by the dark shadows in your room. It is a cool autumn night and your parents have opted to attend a party which you are not allowed at. 'It will be fine,' they s...

50 reviews
Download
Animal Testing

When picking out your mascara or eyeliner, do you even stop to see what kind of makeup you are using? You could be supporting animal cruelty and not even know it. Today many makeup products, such as mascara, are being tested on animals. Helpless and defenseless animals are being performed on for different types of experiments all around the world....

25 reviews
Download
Sexual Violence Against Women

In today's society, isn't a rarity. Every year, large numbers of women are becoming victims of some kind of violent act. This has caused sexual violence to become a growing concern among societies. Let us ask ourselves, "When will it stop?" Women always say to themselves, "It will never happen to me." If you were to look at the number of vict...

27 reviews
Download
Organization Leaders In The Workplace

In today's world, most organizational leaders commonly fear the word power. In America, leaders are confronted by situations that involve a choice of power all the time. A majority of them shy away from power as a means to settle or solve there problems. Most leaders would agree they don't enjoy conflict. Even as we intend to be positive, we mor...

84 reviews
Download
Atsisiųsti šį darbą