- Discover essay samples

Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection under the First Amendment

4.9 of 5.0 (206 reviews)

928 words
Social Issues

Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection under the First Amendment page 1
Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection under the First Amendment page 2
Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection under the First Amendment page 3
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

Should Racist Speech Enjoy Protection under the First Amendment

Prejudice and racial stereotyping are two of this country's greatest problems today. Many people in our society have
tried to find ways to eliminate or at least limit these types of behavior, but have met with very limited, if any, success.
Because of the complex nature of racism and racist acts, coupled with the fact the first amendment prohibits the
government from limiting the publics? right to free expression and speech, the Federal government has been
ineffective in eliminating racist actions that pervade our society. State governments and institutions have attempted to
set up their own laws condemning such actions, but have been wholly unsuccessful.

Some of those waging a war on racism have established anti-discrimination policies, and have had these policies
challenged as a result. Central Michigan University, for example, had instituted a discriminatory harassment policy,
only to have it shot down by the Supreme Court in 1995 on grounds that the policy ?necessarily requires [the]
university to assess racial or ethnic content of speech.? Since Central Michigan University is a State school, the First
Amendment prohibits it from enacting regulations that would limit an individual's right to free speech unless the
regulations, according to a 1986 ruling by the Supreme Court, are ?narrowly and precisely designed.?

As you can imagine, precisely tailoring any statute in order to prohibit racist speech is nearly impossible - and as
many other speakers have already said, banning the current racial slurs will only create new ones. Additionally, an
outright ban on racist speech and ideas could likely lead to a higher level of violence in our society.

A number of other supreme court rulings have come out in favor of protecting all speech, including racist speech,
such as:

A 1941 ruling on the case of Sullens v State, stating that the ?Freedom of speech includes freedom to
speak unwisdom or even heresy.?

A 1949 ruling on the case of Terminillo v Chicago, stating that ?Attacks on racial and religious groups
are protected by right of free speech in absence of showing of serious substantive evil that rises far
above public inconvenience, annoyance, or unrest??

A 1952 ruling on the case of Joseph Burstyn, Inc. v Wilson, stating that: ?[The] First Amendment
prohibits [the] state from banning communication of ideas deemed by some to be blasphemous or

A 1965 ruling on the case of Cox v Louisiana, stating that ?Freedom of speech is of paramount
importance and may not be denied merely because it may create dispute.?

Thus with these rulings, and with the only notable exception being in the case of the utterance of ?fighting words,?
which are defined as ?words which by their very utterance inflict injury or tend to incite immediate breach of peace,?
racist speech is currently protected under the First Amendment.

Some would argue, however, that any racial slur or racist speech has no place in today's society, and that the general
public does not want to hear and should not be subjected to hearing such outright bigotry. But does the right to speak
one's mind outweigh the listener's rights? Apparently, yes, it does. According to the supreme court in the case of the
National Labor Relations Board v Montgomery Ward & Co. (1946), the ?First Amendment is concerned with
freedom of thought and expression of [the] speaker or writer, not with conditions under which [the] auditor receives
[the] message? [the] First Amendment does not require that [an] audience shall have volunteered to listen.? This
ruling essentially invalidates the argument, and forces the listener into a position where he must decide what to listen
to and what to ignore, which is what we all do anyway.

Allowing racist speech is an important thing, though. Without it we would have no ?litmus test? available to test the
racial tension in our country, and would therefore have no way to combat it. By allowing free speech to continue and
by researching other methods of ending racism, we can get at the root of the problem and stop racism before it
starts. The key is not to limit or control action, but rather to influence reason and thought.

There are a number of methods that the government could employ to attempt to eliminate racism from our country.
Campaigns promoting more multi-cultural events and celebrating the differences of everyone in our country may be
effective in changing people's perspective of other races, as the more contact you have with people outside your
?circle? the more comfortable you generally become. A ?Task Force? could also be created to research the problem
of racism, to determine when and how it starts in people, and to find ways to combat it.

The most effective immediate solution, I believe, would be to encourage every business in the country to adopt
zero-tolerance policies regarding racism, and perhaps even have the general policies outlined by the Federal
Government. By passing a law which would establish general guidelines for racism, and by making acceptance and
employment of these guidelines in the workplace criteria for qualifying for certain business tax breaks, the
government would second-handedly affect ...

You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 928 words of 1856.

Similar essays

Gay Marriages

A battle has been in progress for years over whether equal rights and equal protection against discrimination should be extended to homosexuals. Recently this has expanded into the area of marriage. The topic of homosexual marriages is a prevalent issue today. Even in the nation?s capital, representatives are finding ways to make t...

83 reviews
Domestic Violence

Each day, the statistics on get more and more horrifying. A woman is beaten every 15 seconds, 22 to 35 percent of emergency room visits from women are because of ongoing partner abuse, 1 in 4 pregnant women have a history of partner violence, and 63 percent of young men between the ages of 11 and 20 are in jail for murdering their mothers abuser....

194 reviews
Rise of the American Women

The rise of the ?American? women There are many things that were impacted after the World War I and World War II. For instance, there was the ?great migration? that changed the lives of an estimate of a half of a million African-Americans, which were given the opportunity to migrate from the South to the North. They were given t...

31 reviews
Groups In Society

that officially make known minority viewpoints are generally widely stigmatised by the majority as social out-groups (Vaughan and Hogg, 1997). For many theorists, Social Identity (group membership) is an important source of self-esteem, they will cherish what identities they have, fiercely preserving their positive aspects of out-groups, whilst en...

44 reviews
What Is Love? Why Are You Asking Me?

What is Love? Why Are You Asking Me? Upon examination of the vast amounts of theories on love I can only find myself in a more convoluted state. Love is in fact a great mystery to me, and I have only achieved frustration in trying to explicate it. In Scott Peck's book The Roadless Traveled there are a conglomerate of avenues that are explored wit...

203 reviews
The Effects of Race on Sentencing in Capital Punishment Cases

Throughout history, minorities have been ill-represented in the criminal justice system, particularly in cases where the possible outcome is death. In early America, blacks were lynched for the slightest violation of informal laws and many of these killings occured without any type of due process. As the judicial system has matu...

1 reviews
The Obstacles In Raising Nonracist Children

Instructor: Dr. Katharina Rout It is my goal as a parent to raise my children to be nonracist. In order to achieve this goal, I need to observe and assess everything my children will be exposed to, be it in the media, opinions of their relatives or the opinions and actions from certain groups within the Canadian society. The racial state...

17 reviews

I. Description of Communist Problem is a system of government where all the countries major resources in the are controlled by the Federal Government (Encarta). It is based on the principal that everyone gives the same and everyone receives the same amount of stuff. No one gets any more or any less. In theory, everyone provides the equal amount of...

4 reviews
Prison System

Prison inmates, are some of the most ?maladjusted? people in society. Most of the inmates have had too little discipline or too much, come from broken homes, and have no self-esteem. They are very insecure and are ?at war with themselves as well as with society? (Szumski 20). Most inmates did not learn moral values or learn to foll...

109 reviews
Poverty And Welfare

Today it seems as if everyone has a theory about fighting poverty, now it is not necessary to be moving in the theoretical plane. Our country has had successful anti-poverty programs that were effective back a century ago, effective because they were based on these seven points: affiliation, bonding, categorization, discernment, employment, freedo...

124 reviews
The War Of Freedom Of Expression

"Taking on anti-Semites and Holocaust deniers in the sanctified courtroom environment is like responding to someone who calls your mother a prostitute. By defending you raise the question that maybe she really was" Anonymous source drawn from Weiman and Win, 1986. The right to freedom of expression can be described as a war. It is a war tha...

209 reviews
How To Win An Argument

To win an argument one must keep in mind the following factors: Is the argument worth fighting? Do you have the proper background to win the argument? Who is your opponent? And finally, do I have the proper argumentative behavior. Before getting involved in an argument, you must decide whether or not it is even worth fighting. Does the subject at h...

199 reviews
The Politics of Gun Control

In recent years, political discourse about gun control and the Second Amendment has become increasingly volatile. Gun lobbies such as the National Rifle Association are more organized and aggressive and their issue agenda has evolved as new and more powerful weapons and militia appear. On the other side of the debate, the critical...

92 reviews
Television That Kills

Television has changed over time. It used to be a wholesome activity for the family to sit in front of the tube together. It was a new technology that brought the outside world into the living room. Now TV, as it has so lovingly been dubbed, has become a source of corruption for the nation's children. As the world becomes more and more violent the...

152 reviews
Atsisiųsti šį darbą