- Discover essay samples

Male Circumcision: A Social And Medical Misconception

4.9 of 5.0 (141 reviews)

768 words

Male Circumcision: A Social And Medical Misconception page 1
Male Circumcision: A Social And Medical Misconception page 2
Male Circumcision: A Social And Medical Misconception page 3
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

University of Johns Hopkins
Male circumcision is defined as a surgical procedure in which the prepuce
of the penis is separated from the glands and excised. (Mosby, 1986) Dating as
far back as 2800 BC, circumcision has been performed as a part of religious
ceremony, as a puberty or premarital rite, as a disciplinary measure, as a
reprieve against the toxic effects of vaginal blood, and as a mark of slavery.
(Milos & Macris, 1992) In the United States, advocacy of circumcision was
perpetuated amid the Victorian belief that circumcision served as a remedy
against the ills of masturbation and systemic disease. (Lund, 1990) The
scientific community further reinforced these beliefs by reporting the incidence
of hygiene-related urogenital disorders to be higher in uncircumcised men.
Circumcision is now a societal norm in the United States. Routine
circumcision is the most widely practiced pediatric surgery and an estimated one
to one-and-a-half million newborns, or 80 to 90 percent of the population, are
circumcised. (Lund, 1990) Despite these statistics, circumcision still remains a
topic of great debate. The medical community is examining the need for a
surgical procedure that is historically based on religious and cultural doctrine
and not of medical necessity. Possible complications of circumcision include
hemorrhage, infection, surgical trauma, and pain. (Gelbaum, 1992) Unless
absolute medical indications exist, why should male infants be exposed to these
risks? In essence, our society has perpetuated an unnecessary surgical procedure
that permanently alters a normal, healthy body part.
This paper examines the literature surrounding the debate over circumcision,
delineates the flaws that exist in the research, and discusses the nurse's role
in the circumcision debate.

Review of Literature

Many studies performed worldwide suggest a relationship between lack of
circumcision and urinary tract infection (UTI). In 1982, Ginsberg and McCracken
described a case series of infants five days to eight months of age hospitalized
with UTI. (Thompson, 1990) Of the total infant population hospitalized with UTI,
sixty-two were males and only three were circumcised. (Thompson, 1990) Based on
this information, the researchers speculated that, "the uncircumcised male has
an increased susceptibility to UTI." Subsequently, Wiswell and associates from
Brooke Army Hospital released a series of papers based upon a retrospective
cohort study design of children hospitalized with UTI in the first year of life.
The authors conclusions suggest a 10 to 20-fold increase in risk for UTI in the
uncircumcised male in the first year of life. (Thompson, 1990) However, Thompson
(1990) reports that in these studies analysis of the data was very crude and
there were no controls for the variables of age, race, education level, or
income. The statistical findings from further studies are equally misconstruing.
In 1986, Wiswell and Roscelli reported an increase in the number of UTIs as the
circumcision rate declined. By clearly leaving out "aberrant data", the results
of the study are again very misleading. In 1989, Herzog from Boston Children's
Hospital reported on a retrospective case-control study on the relationship
between the incidence of UTI and circumcision in the male infant under one year
of age. Here too, the results were not adjusted to account for the variables of
age, ethnicity, and drop-out rate of the participants. It is obvious that this
research is statistically weak and should not be the criteria on which to decide
for or against neonatal circumcision.
Lund (1990) reports that a study conducted by Parker and associates
estimates the relative risk of uncircumcised males to be double that of
circumcised males for acquiring herpes genitalis, candidiasis, gonorrhea, and
syphilis. Simonsen and coworkers performed a case-control study on 340 men in
Kenya, Africa in an attempt to explain the different pattern for acquired immune
deficiency syndrome (AIDS) virus in Africa as compared to the United States.
(Thompson, 1990) The authors conclude that the relative risk for AIDS was higher
for uncircumcised men. Results from similar studies in the United States remain
conflicting. Although most of the existing studies do associate a relationship
between the incidence of venereal disease and circumcision, the American Academy
of Pediatrics found existing reports inconclusive and conflicting in results.
(Lund, 1990) There is an overwhelming incidence of STD and AIDS in the United
States, where a majority of the men are circumcised.
It is imperative that we look at ways of altering our risk of exposure to
these agents than at ...

You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 768 words of 1535.

Keywords: male circumcision research, male circumcision and std prevention, male circumcision feminism

Similar essays

No One Can Prepare Themselves For A Sudden Death

There are few things in life that are harder to explain to a child then death. Too frequently this task falls on a family member already struggling with their own grief. Nobody likes imagining dealing with a death of a loved one. Unfortunately the odds are high that some point you will face this situation. This may result to the death of a parent,...

68 reviews

is caused by a bacterium called Neisseria gonorrhoeae, (commonly known as 'the clap') which grows and multiplies, quickly in moist, warm areas of the body including the reproductive tract, the oral cavity, and the rectum. One in five people in the U.S. have a STD. One in every 687 Americans has , a rate of two million people means that one in eve...

41 reviews
EMDR Eye Movement

Throughout phases 4 through 6 of EMDR clients concentrate on their disturbing or desired occurrences at the same time as they attend to a dual attention stimulus. Eye movements dual attention stimulus are the most commonly used, but tapping, tactile stimulation, and auditory tones are used as well. These are generally offered in an alternating bila...

169 reviews
Palliative Care

The world of nursing has many ethical issues. One of these close to me is palliative care. The type of care given to a patient and their family during the final days of ones life. Many registered nurses (RN) seem to not think about what if they or their loved one was the patient. Many nurses when caring for a patient that seems to be in a vegata...

25 reviews
AIDS Esssay

Typically, people in today's world cast those with AIDS off into an unwanted world of immorality. The world sees AIDS as people who have had a history with drugs or the homosexual life. One would most likely consider AIDS a moral issue. AIDS has an affect on everyone- we have to make a decision on whether or not we will choose to take part in th...

208 reviews
Alcohol: Most Used And Abused Drug

Alcohol is the most used and abused drug in the world, for this reason there is no wonder why we have alcohol problems. The most common problem is alcoholism. Alcoholism is a chronic usually progressive disease that includes both a psychological and a physical addiction to alcohol. Alcoholics know what will happen to them when they drink but the...

158 reviews

This is an age of modern living, superior technology, luxurious day-to-day, exaggerated money and last but not the least trending obesity. Growing number of cases of obesity has made it into a fully grown social problem. Child obesity is a much talked about topic in today's era. What could be the cause of this? The modernization of our living has t...

171 reviews
The Dangers Of Smoking

About 400,000 Americans die every year because of health problems due to smoking. 1.5 million people quit smoking a year, but 50 million keep on going. Those 50 million people are addicted to nicotine. Nicotine addiction is when a person psychologically, physically, and socially has a compulsive need for nicotine. There is a persistent craving...

155 reviews
Suicide Solution

I'm about to take up a position which is going to be deamed by some, if not all, as a terrible stand to take. As a matter of fact, if anyone were to agree with me on ths subject, I'd be surprsed. For you see, rather than arguing from the postion of suicide being an unjustified and inane way to die, I shall argue the other point. That being suicide...

202 reviews
Decisions About Abortion

I am not really for or against abortion, all I have are opinions about the idea. I believe that it's not right to have a partial birth abortion, that it should be up to the pregnant woman to decide whether or not she wants to do it, and that men shouldn't have any say in this. To have a partial birth abortion, to me, is murder. If something has a p...

49 reviews
Turner's Syndrome

A relatively uncommon human sex-chromosome disorder. Males very rarely contract this disease. Its occurrence rate in females is about one per 3,000 live female births. Occurs when a sperm carrying no sex chromosomes fertilizes a normal ovum, resulting in a female that has only one X chromosome, producing a male body type: short, with a broad n...

19 reviews
AIDS: A U.S.- Made Monster?

PREFACE In an extensive article in the Summer-Autumn 1990 issue of "Top Secret", Prof J. Segal and Dr. L. Segal outline their theory that AIDS is a man-made disease, originating at Pentagon bacteriological warfare labs at Fort Detrick, Maryland. "Top Secret" is the international edition of the German magazine Geheim and is considered by many to be...

81 reviews
MRI Memo

writing #3-MRI memo January 16, 2014 TO: Emily Williams RE: patients with pacemakers Understandably, patients with the old pacemakers should not be allowed to have MRI scans, since we know that the MRI machine contains a very strong magnet. When people go into the machine, the hydrogen atoms in their body line up with the magnetic field. The mach...

118 reviews

The parents of six year old James Patrick Smith receive a phone call from the school guidance counselor informing them of their child's recent hyperactive behavior. After a short conference, the guidance counselor suggests to the parents a solution for young James' problem; as a result, the family visits their family doctor and the doctor diagnoses...

182 reviews
Atsisiųsti šį darbą