- Discover essay samples

In Depth Analysis Of Keats' 'Ode On A Grecian Urn'

4.9 of 5.0 (104 reviews)

1049 words
Poetry & Poets

In Depth Analysis Of Keats' 'Ode On A Grecian Urn' Page 1
In Depth Analysis Of Keats' 'Ode On A Grecian Urn' Page 2
In Depth Analysis Of Keats' 'Ode On A Grecian Urn' Page 3
In Depth Analysis Of Keats' 'Ode On A Grecian Urn' Page 4
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

John Keats's 'Ode on a Grecian Urn' depicts a timeless theme relevant in any society throughout the history of our civilization. Through his use of movement and of language, Keats has created a work of art in its own right whose overall idea and inspiration will remain unchanged generation after generation.
The necessity for infusion into all creatures and things in order to achieve some sense of the poetical and unchangeable permeates Keats'' Odes written in 1819, particularly 'Nightingale' and 'Grecian Urn.' While Keats was writing the Odes, he could not be unaware of his own troublesome health, and at the same time, was entirely too aware of the recent passing of his brother Tom. Despite such heartbreaking troubles, he composes 'Ode on a Grecian Urn' in an attempt to find poetical existence beyond his too-short human lifetime.
As Keats tries to find some sense of permanence in an ever more apparently impermanent and fleeting world, he turns to those objects which he regards to as outside of the temporality he, as a mortal man experiences: the perpetuating, generationless song of the nightingale and the 'cold Pastoral' ageless marble scenes on the Grecian Urn, considered by may to be among the 'best' of his poetry. Ex:
His best poetry is composed largely of representations of representations, meditations 'on' objects or texts that are themselves reflections of other artists' creative acts (Scott, xi).
The product of these artists are indeed timeless and eternal, something Keats was very aware, both in presence of other artists works and in the absence of his own. As Keats tries to create for himself a place among these eternal artists, he tries to perpetuate dialogue with both the past and the future by applying a style that allows him to create a "work of art" by describing 'works of art, to translate the arrested visual image into the fluid movement of words' (Scott 1). Scott, in his book The Sculpted Word, goes on to say that 'Keats must achieve what the heroes of antiquity were given-- namely their assured place in the cultural order' (Scot 1).
The ambiguities, uncertainties, and still remaining questions provoked by 'Ode on a Grecian Urn' have generated thousands of pages of criticism. From the beginning of the first stanza, the reader is probed with a series of questions issued by the poem's speaking subject. Keats then allows the urn to speak without speaking, to 'express/ A flowery tale more sweetly than our rhyme.' However, as Keats himself cannot get outside of the answers that he continually struggles with throughout his career, he issues a series of questions that he 'expects' the urn, or those represented on the urn to answer. Scott notes, ''the ode does not begin with speaker's attempt to compete with the urn, but with an homage to its strange genealogy and to its paradoxical powers of eloquence' (Scott 135). Scott also states that Keats immediately becomes impatient with the urn's silence and seeks to impose his own dialogue on the existing surface of the urn. Andrew Bennet also notices Keats's desire to enter into the dialogue, saying that Keats 'always seems about to burst into narrative' (Bennett 130). He seems right from the beginning to be questioning the urn, and then imposing his own answers. Then in urn fashion, Keats becomes as willfully ambiguous as the urn, ultimately haunting readers at the end of the poem by questioning the nature of Truth as represented by this urn and by his poem. As Stillinger accurately notes in The Hoodwinking of Madeline that the real question of the urn is 'Who says what to whom at the end of 'Ode on a Grecian Urn'?' (Stillinger 167-173).
The origin of truth must in some way relate to who we identify as the speaking subject in the poem. 'Ode on a Grecian Urn' was published three times ' with three different versions of the famous last lines, controversy surrounding the use of quotation marks and certain capitalizations (or their absence). Considering that something or someone is addressing the readers directly at the end of the poem, and that this someone is 'a friend to man,' it is important to investigate the nature of the speaking subject in 'Grecian Urn'. Keats, therefore, uses his relation to the urn to construct various narratives for the scenes. He sees the 'happy' lover and the object of his desire, the piper, the tree boughs, and the sacrificial procession. The urn's scenes, containing superficially wholesome and lovely scenes, are, nevertheless, ambiguous in their meanings, hence, Keats' insistent questioning throughout the first and fourth stanzas. He demands origins, names and specifics regarding certain represented events. These unanswerable questions are then left open to the viewer's own construction by the sculptor. Keats, knowing that he cannot know, poses his own interpretations for what stories the urn reveals.
According to Jason Mauro, author of 'The Shape of despair' Structure and Vision in Keats's Ode on a Grecian Urn,' is that this particular ode inscribes a sine wave, with five distinctive points along its length. Example:

First: The poet is steeped in despair brought about by the world's unrelenting flux.
Second: Upon encountering the urn, he is filled with the hope that he has found an antidote to his despair.
Third: He finds that his hope is unfounded, -- that the antidote was no more than a placebo.
Fourth: As he more closely examines the urn, he finds that it embodies a terror far more intense than the despair from which he originally sought relief; that the placebo is in fact a poison.
Last: He embraces the transient condition of the world as an antidote to the terror inherent in the urn.

What was interesting about Mauro's sine-wave theory to the ode, is that the point of origin, --the poet's initial despair from which he wishes to ascend, -- becomes the point of salvation to which, by the end of the poem he wishes to climb.
Different scholars argue about the possible existence of an 'actual' tangible urn that may have inspired Keats to write his ode. There is a presumed sketch of a vase in the archives of the Keats-Shelley Memorial house in ...

You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 1049 words of 2098.

Keywords: ode on a grecian urn analysis beauty is truth, analysis of ode on grecian urn, analysis of ode on a grecian urn pdf, ode on a grecian urn is about

Similar essays

Anyone Lived In A Pretty How Town

I don't think the poem means to say that anyone and noone are the cool guys, whereas the 'women and men' are boring types who don't understand. 'Anyone' is just that - any individual. He is special because everyone is special. We don't appreciate this because we all lead such busy lives - we are all the 'women and men' who don't notice things. 'Noo...

209 reviews
All My Pretty Ones

In several literary works, there is an underlying tension between the parents and their children. One example of this parental conflict can be seen in Anne Sexton's '.' The poem details the sentiments of a child who has lost both of her parents within a very short period of time and who addresses her father in a sympathetic tone. As a result, the c...

36 reviews
The Poetry Of William Cullen Bryant And Emily Dickinson: The Theme Of Death

Many poems are written about death. The two poets William Cullen Bryant and Emily Dickinson were very influential trancendental writers. Bryant writing Thanatopsis And Emily Dickinson's "Because I Could Not Stop for Death" are basically more alike then than they are similar for the fact that there views on Death are the same, but what happens to yo...

126 reviews
E.E. Cummings

E. E. Cummings, who was born in 1894 and died in 1962, wrote many poems with unconventional punctuation and capitalization, and unusual line, word, and even letter placements. Cummings' most difficult form of prose is probably the ideogram; it is extremely short and it combines both visual and aural elements. There may be sounds or characters on t...

192 reviews
Turtles Hatching

In Mark O'Connor describes the early moments of newly hatched turtles; the turtles begin the race of life, with their sights set on the sea, overcoming the many difficulties and obstacles they face. O'Connor portrays that for every moment spent on the beach, the chance of surviving becomes more, and more slim. He describes merciless predators, w...

88 reviews
Suburban Sonnet Summary

Title: Suburban Sonnet, Gwen Harwood Subject Matter: This piece exposes the mixed blessing of children and the darker side of motherhood. Analysis: Key Quotes Techniques and Impact on Reader "zest and love, drain out with soapy water" This image has been juxtaposed against "zest and love", enhancing the way they have seeped from her existence * "d...

122 reviews
Analysis Of Heaney's Punishment

Question: "On the surface, Heaney's poems are very simple. This simplicity however is deceptive, for the poems are usually most subtle and complex." What do you think of this response to Heaney's poems? Heaney's poetry may at first, initially seem simple, yet his poems do contain more complex underlying themes and ideas. Heaney has refined his poet...

57 reviews
Edgar Allan Poe's "The Black Cat"

"The Black Cat," which first appeared in the United States Saturday Post (The Saturday Evening Post) on August 19, 1843, serves as a reminder for all of us. The capacity for violence and horror lies within each of us, no matter how docile and humane our dispositions might appear. - By Martha Womack Martha Womack, better known to Internet users as...

20 reviews
Crossing Brooklyn Ferry: One And The Same

Walt Whitman asks himself and the reader of the poem, "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry," what significance a person's life holds in the scope of densely populated planet. The poem explores the difficulties of discovering the relevance of life. The methods that helped Whitman grasp his own idea of the importance of life are defined with some simple yet in...

15 reviews
Odysseus's Worst Choice

Odysseus took many different trips and experienced many adventures before arriving home. Out of all his wanderings, his worst choice was the land of the Cyclops. This is where Odysseus and his men were trapped in a Cyclops' cave, Polyphemus, the son of Poseidon. There, he lost a couple of his men by being eaten from Polyphemus. His plan to escape...

204 reviews
Mending Wall and New Year Comparison

Introduction The poems `Mending Wall' and `New year' written by Robert Frost and Edward Thomas are both similar in the idea that they both revolve around encounters. Both poems have many similarities in their presentation and ideas but are also very contrasting. Both have encounters, presented in different ways, some of the key ideas however remai...

40 reviews
Poema 15

Este poema "me gustas cuando callas porque est?s como ausente", es el n?mero 15 de la obra Veinte poemas de amor y una canci?n desesperada. Trata sobre los sentimientos que tiene el hacia ella. Para ?l lo m?s importante es ella. Este poema se podr?a dividir en dos partes: La primera parte estar?a comprendida desde el verso 1, hasta el verso...

197 reviews
Response to 'The Chambered Nautilus'

When I first read the poem, it was kind of confusing and hard to understand. It wasn't until I read it the second time that I figured out that Oliver Holmes was actually writing about a sea creature, or, at least I think that's what he's writing about. What convinces me that he's writing about a sea creature is the fact that the setting for the p...

106 reviews
Interpreting Poetry

What the heck does that mean?' Many people have found themselves asking that question when reading poetry. So in order to help get a general idea of what poems say, it is necessary to look at some examples of poetry and try to decide what, if anything, the poet is trying to say. Three poems, each by a different author, which all basically follow...

140 reviews
Atsisiųsti šį darbą