- Discover essay samples

Differences And Similarities Of Liberalism

4.9 of 5.0 (121 reviews)

1158 words

Differences And Similarities Of Liberalism Page 1
Differences And Similarities Of Liberalism Page 2
Differences And Similarities Of Liberalism Page 3
Differences And Similarities Of Liberalism Page 4
Differences And Similarities Of Liberalism Page 5
Differences And Similarities Of Liberalism Page 6
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

The purpose of this paper is to treat the similarly and differences of
liberalism. I will use John Locke and Adam Smith to represent classical
liberals. John Stuart Mill and John Maynard Keynes will be used to show
contemporary liberals.

John Locke

In John Locke's Second Treatise of Government he develops a theory of
government as a product of a social contract, which when broken justifies the
creation of a new government for the protection of life, liberty and property.
He begins his argument by developing a theory of the state of nature which is

...what state all men are naturally in, and that is, a state of
perfect freedom to order their actions and dispose of their
possessions and persons as they think fit, within the bounds
of the law of nature, without asking leave or depending upon
the will of any other man.1

The state of nature includes the ' of nature to govern it, which obliges
everyone; and reason, which is that law, teaches all mankind who will but
consult it...'2 The state of nature also includes inequality

...since gold and silver, being little useful to the life of a
man in proportion to food, raiment, and carriage, has its value
only from the consent of men, whereof labour yet makes, in
great part, the measure, it is plain that men have agreed to a
disproportional and unequal possession of the earth.3

In Locke's state on nature there are also three distinct problems. First
there is no established settled known law. As each man consults his own law of
nature he receives a slightly different interpretation.
Secondly there no known and indifferent judge. Which creates the
problem of trying to decide which is the correct law of nature which will be
followed in an impartial manor.
Thirdly there is insufficient force of execution. This is the problem
of how to carry out the decision of the law of nature on another when he has a
different interpretation or doesn't consult the law of nature.
Locke states that the three problems in the state of nature would be
best solved by coming together to form a new government to protect there

The great and chief end therefore, of men's coming into commonwealths,
and putting themselves under government, is the preservation of their

And goes further into what this new government should be empowered to do

firstly...established, settled known law, received and allowed by
common consent to be the standard of right and wrong, and the
common measure to decide all controversies between them...
secondly...there wants a known and indifferent judge, with
authority to determine all differences according to the
established law...thirdly...There often wants power to back
and support the sentence when right, and to give it due execution.
They who by any injustice offend, will seldom fail, where they
are able, by force to make good their injustice...5

In Locke's government men only give up the right to the above mentioned
things, to create the law for themselves, to judge the law for themselves, and
to execute the law for themselves. These are the only rights that the
government has the right to interfere in as it is the only reason that people
entered into a commonwealth. Locke also explains the new social contract that
the new government should operate under. The first point of the contract is
that the people agree to form a body politic, in which the majority rule.
Second the body politic selects a government of the day. (elects people on a
regular basis to the government to legislate the law)
Locke laid out who should be allowed the right to vote, who shouldn't be
allowed to vote and gives his reason why.

...all men as members for the purposes of being ruled and only men
of estate as members for the prepossess of ruling. The right to
rule (more accurately, the right to control any government) is
given to the men of estate only: it is they who are given the
decisive voice about taxation, without which no government can
subsist. On the other hand, the obligation to be bound by law
and subject to the lawful government is fixed on all men whether
or not they have property in the sense of estate, and indeed
whether or not they have made an express compact.6

Johns Stuart Mill

There is no difficulty in showing that the ideally best form of
government is that
in which the sovereignty, or supreme controlling power in the last
resort, is
vested in the entire aggregate of the community.7
It is with this statement that Mill begins his augment in The Ideally
Best Polity showing his believe in Locke's democracy but saying that all people
could be best served by the government if everyone could vote. As this is the
only way the government learns what it needs to know in order to govern. He
comes to this concussion by saying that participatory democracy is the best
answer to the two questions that he poses as to what makes a good government.

...namely how far it promotes the good management of the affairs
of society by means of the existing faculties, moral, intellectual,
and active, of its various members, and what effect in improving or
deteriorating those faculties.8

Mill believes that it is necessary to expand the role of government not
only to protect the people from the government but to promote liberty by putting
limits on what can be expressed as public opinion against a minority, and to
involve people in the government so as to give them stimulation and help them
In Mill's writings he also discuses the idea of liberty and what limits
government and public opinion should have on interfering with a individuals

...the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised
over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to
prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral,
is not a sufficient warrant.9

Differences Between Locke and Mill

Although Locke and Mill both believe in government by and for the
governed there chief difference is in the idea of who the government is for.
Where Locke believes that ...

You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 1158 words of 2315.

Keywords: differences and similarities of liberalism and anarchism, similarities and difference of liberalism, similarities and differences of liberalism brainly, similarities and differences of liberalism and conservatism, similarities and differences of liberalism and socialism, what are the similarities of liberalism and socialism, how are liberalism and realism similar

Similar essays

How to play asshole

To all you incoming college freshman that don't want to make a fool of yourself at college parties, learn this drinking game. Perhaps the King of all drinking games, Asshole is a true American classic. Asshole is a game that tests one's ability to concentrate, as well as one's threshold for humiliation, for the object of the game is for those...

58 reviews
Indonesia Crisis As An Example

Indonesia's Crisis: The Lesson for China introductionIndonesia, as we have long predicted, is coming apart. This process has a great deal of relevance to China, whose army, like Indonesia's, was accustomed to making lots of money and now resents the fact that the good times are over. In both countries, making money became the basis for military loy...

25 reviews
Serial killers 3

At a time when violent crime is dropping, one category of deceptively dangerous people -- serial killers -- is causing alarm from coast to coast with seemingly motiveless murders. These people are not creatures or animals who can easily be identified. Serial killers are hard to find and virtually undetectable until they start murdering the in...

206 reviews
Uniform commercial code 2b the

A new law will probably be introduced into state legislatures which will govern all contracts for the development, sale, licensing, and support of computer software. This law, which has been in development for about ten years, will be an amendment to the Uniform Commercial Code. The amendment is called Article 2B (Law of Licensing) and is loose...

157 reviews

England is famous for its educational institutes. It has some of the most famous universities of the world like Oxford, and London universities. The city of is in the county of shire and is famous because it is the home of University, one of the oldest and most prestigious universities of the world. The City occupies an area of 16 squa...

59 reviews

.s. high schools .S.high schools are not properly preparing kids for the college experience. The primary purpose of a high school in the nited States is to get kids into college. The courses taught in .S.high schools are way too lenient in their grading policies and offer students much leeway.High school courses are too lenient because high scho...

40 reviews
The evolution of professional

WRESTLING Wrestling is defined as a sport in which the opponents wrestle, or struggle hand to hand. This has been done for thousands of years. Wrestling is probably one of the oldest sports in the world. Along with the discovery of mummies, gold, and priceless artifacts that had not been seen by human eyes in thousands of years. There...

30 reviews
Hobbes philosophy

Born during a period of medieval philosophy, Thomas Hobbes developed a new way of thinking. He perfected his moral and political theories in his controversial book Leviathan, written in 1651. In his introduction, Hobbes describes the state of nature as an organism analogous to a large person (p.42). He advises that people should look into thems...

30 reviews

In ancient Greece, the most feared named was Sparta. It was a total war machine willing to take on all comers. They rose above the rest by being well disciplined and educated. The man who brought them this glory was . Like any great leader he was very idealistic. His main goal was to change Sparta into a complete city state. It is believed...

52 reviews
Evolution Of Profanity

The evolution of written profanity began roughly in the sixteenth century, and continues to change with each generation that it sees. Profanity is recognized in many Shakespearean works, and has continually evolved into the profane language used today. Some cuss words have somehow maintained their original meanings throughout hundreds of yea...

7 reviews
Formula One Racing

Formula One racing, or F1, is known to be the most prestigious type of auto racing in the world. Unfortunately, in the United States F1 racing is not nearly as popular as other motorsports such as Nascar. On a typical Sunday afternoon if one were to flip channels on the television, Nascar would most likely be airing on a...

131 reviews
The World Of Perfumes

Few would dispute the importance of petroleum to the world economy. In fact, some argue that in 1991 the United States and its allies fought a war in the Persian Gulf over this liquid that, at current prices, cost less than half a cent per fluid ounce and doesn't even smell all that good. Imagine the lengths one might go to protect access to a liqu...

47 reviews
Body Piercing Will You Conform

People claiming that they are expressing thier individuality throught body piercing need to take a reality check. Everyone these days is putting rings and spikes in every conceivable body part these days. In fact hat wasonce a form of rebellion is now a simple reproduction of and underground society. Body piercing has gone from mild to medium to...

42 reviews
Overpopulation 2

There are 6 billion human beings on the face of the Earth. According to our best estimates, there are somewhere between three and seven times more people than this planet can possibly maintain over a long period of time. Non-renewable resources are being used at an incredible rate, and we are destroying the capability of the planetary ecosystem to...

148 reviews
Atsisiųsti šį darbą