- Discover essay samples

Can Skepticism Be Defended, Perhaps In A Limited Form?

4.9 of 5.0 (43 reviews)

990 words

Can Skepticism Be Defended, Perhaps In A Limited Form? page 1
Can Skepticism Be Defended, Perhaps In A Limited Form? page 2
Can Skepticism Be Defended, Perhaps In A Limited Form? page 3
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

1. Introduction
This essay centres around what it means to know something is true and also why
it is important to distinguish between what you know and do not or can not know.

The sceptic in challenging the possibility of knowing anything challenges the
basis on which all epistemology is based. It is from this attack on epistemology
that the defence of scepticism is seen.

2. Strong Scepticism

Strong scepticism states that it is not possible to know anything. That is we
cannot have absolute knowledge of anything. This can however immediately have
the reflexive argument turned on it and have the question begged of it: 'If it
is not possible to know anything then how is it you know that nothing is
knowable ?'. Strong Scepticism is therefore unable to be defended.

3. A Definition of Knowledge

Knowledge can be said to be information that the brain has received that meets a
certain set of criteria. When someone states that they know something they must
also believe that, that something is so. If they did not believe in it then how
could they take it in as knowledge ?, they would instead be doubtful of it and
look for evidence or justification as to why they should believe it.

Secondly for someone to believe in something they must also believe that it is
true. If they did not believe that it was true then what is mentioned above
would not occur.

So, so far it is decided that knowledge should be true belief. How does one come
to the conclusion that something is true however ?. We seek justification. The
justification really is the most important part of the criteria because without
it one cannot say something is true and therefore cannot say that one believes.

This does however bring up the question of how does something become justified ?,
do we hear it from other people ?, see it on the news ?. The justification of
something really depends on its predictability. If something becomes predictable
then it can becomes justified aswell. For example, I know that the sun will rise
tomorrow is a fair thing to say because I believe this is so, I believe this is
true, and I am justified in believing this due to my past experience* of the
predictableness of the sun rising each day.

The only problem with meeting the set of criteria laid out above is that one
must use one senses to do so and as shall be shown in the next section they are
not the most reliable of instruments.

4. Perceptions

A persons sensual perceptions are generally their means of receiving information
but how much can we trust our senses ?. Two examples of a persons sensual
perception leading them astray are as follows.

Two people are looking at a white object. The first person is looking at the
object through a transparent red sheet and the other through a transparent green
sheet. Neither person knows that the sheets are there so both come away with
different conclusions and perceptions as to what colour the object in front of
them is. (Cornman, Lehrer, Pappas, 1992, pp. 46-47)

Another example is when two people are looking at an oblong object from
different angles one may see a perfect rectangle the other a perfect square.
(Cornman, Lehrer, Pappas, 1992, pp. 46-47)

The point I am making here is that sensual perceptions are all relevant to the
position of the observer. This is not a good situation for something that we
contrive to get justification for our knowledge from.

5. The Brain in the Vat Argument

This argument is similar to the one in Plato's republic in that it involves an
imaginary situation where the people or person involved believes that they have
knowledge (Plato, Cave Analogy, Book VII).

In the brain in the vat example the brain believes that it is a fully
functioning human being and there exists an external world around it. The reason
for the brain believing that it knows this is that it has reasonable belief due
to the fact that everything in it's environment coheres, this is obviously not
so however if everything does not cohere (Harrison, 1966-67, pp 179-189).

The sceptical argument from this however is that it is impossible to know
anything if one does not know the initial fact that one is a brain in a vat.
This can be shown as follows.

Suppose that you claim to know that you are sitting reading a book. You
presumably also know that if you are sitting reading, you are not a brain in a
vat. We can surely conclude that if you know that you are sitting reading, you
know that you are not a brain in a vat, and hence (by simple modus tollens) that
since you don't know that you are not a brain in a vat (agreed above) you don't
know you are sitting reading. (Dancy, 1985, p. 10).

The epistemist rejoin however states that this does not matter. The reason given
is that since there is no perceptible difference between being a brain in a vat
being fed sense data and sitting reading then there is nothing of importance
that relies on this distinction. This can be said to be the case. The reason for
this is that if the brain in the vat's environment coheres then it is possible
for the brain in the vat to know something about ...

You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 990 words of 1979.

Keywords: skepticism of authority

Similar essays

Landscape Of History

The city was cloaked with the remains of winter, frigid with a subtle breeze, the kind that made you take a second breath. Spokane the town of sorrows, the town of nothing as I refer to it. Everything was either dead or holding on to the last bit of life it had left just to have a fighting chance to see the first glimpse of spring. Flowers droop...

78 reviews
The internet terms

INTERNET TERMS TERMS TO KNOW: 1. Anonymous FTP A traditional form of login to a public ftp site where the username is given as 'anonymous' and the password is your e-mail address, for example ''. See ftp. 2. Archie/Telnet/Veronica 1. A storage repository for software, data, or other materials to be save...

12 reviews
Civilization Cure Or Disease

Upon flipping to the business section of the New York Times an Ohio University student saw a startling headline glaring back at her 'American Corporations Suspected In Millions of Third World Deaths.' As she read the article it became apparent that international corporations many of which were based in the United States exploit the poorest of...

138 reviews
Effects of graffiti 2

Douglas Barmore What constitutes as graffiti? Grafiti is defined as any type of writing on a surface of any type. If that is the case, then would a cave mans drawings be considered graffiti? If it is considered graffiti, then what is different about then and now that would change the worlds views about graffiti. Why is graffiti agains...

141 reviews
The analysis of the blue marbl

The Analysis of the Blue Marble Throughout history, there has been tremendous progress made on the part of mankind. We, as a species, have been able to tame fire, learn to hunt, survive in extreme conditions, and use our resources to their fullest potential. But do we overuse our resources? I strongly believe that we, as a population, do...

19 reviews
Advantages and disadvantages o

Just as there is to everything else in life, there are costs and benefits to advertising. Advertising plays a major role in our lives. Everywhere you turn there is some form of advertising taking place. Companies spend outrageous amounts to get the attention of the viewer and hold it long enough to increase sales of there product. An example of...

134 reviews
Middle adulthood 2

The Dictionary of Social Work roughly defines middle adulthood as the period between forty-five and sixty-four years of age. There are four main tasks in this stage. They include meeting intimacy and family needs, satisfying achievement needs, taking care of elderly parents, and coping with end of life issues. Erikson identifies the need for...

192 reviews
Goodfellas the Movie, Sociolog

The movie "Goodfellas" is a dramatization of life in the New York Mafia. It is based on the accounts of real life ex-gangster turned state evidence. He tells his story from when he was hired by a wiseguy as a teenager in the fifties to the time he is put in the witness protection program in the seventies. The movie portrays the spirit of the...

101 reviews
In search of your own identity

After various writings by Richard Rodriguez and Octavio Paz, I have come across several realizations. Who am I? Should I be a part of a nation and a ?system? that does not value me, or should I be a part of a nation that does not acknowledge my existence? The United States as a nation does not value me, and M'xico does not even know that I e...

49 reviews
Motivation 2

Motivation is the willingness to exert high levels of effort toward organizational goals, conditioned by the effort's ability to satisfy some individual needs (Robbins, 168). For some business analysts, employee motivation is a good way to increase productivity in an organization. When people get motivated, they will have a reason to put more e...

86 reviews
What does it mean to be americ

What does it mean to be "American?" What makes it "American?" And how does it make us "American?" American stands for the beliefs, the music, as well as the people that come from this great nation. The beliefs of this great nation speak every language. These beliefs stretch from the furthest reaches of Africa to the city lif...

142 reviews

The first item of discussion in Socrates' argument is the separation of the body and the soul. Socrates gains full agreement from Simmias and Cebes when he says that death is simply a separation of the body and the soul. He then makes the argument that this parting is what the philosopher should look forward to and work for. Socrates al...

51 reviews
The dog fight

The year was 1996 and the USA were at war with the Russians, because the USA tried to take over Russian land. The Russians had been threatening the USA. If they didn't back down they would bomb Colorado, one of the biggest cities in USA. It was a cool misty morning when we got the word. The Russians were about to invade the state capit...

21 reviews
Process essay 2

Purchasing Power Parity and International Commodity Arbitrage Foreign Exchange Foreign exchange refers to two different things. The first is currency claims expressed in the equivalent value in foreign money. The second is actual transactions involving the conversion of money of one country into that of another. Foreign excha...

120 reviews
Atsisiųsti šį darbą