- Discover essay samples

Analysis Of Heaney's Punishment

4.9 of 5.0 (57 reviews)

525 words
Poetry & Poets

Analysis Of Heaney's Punishment Page 1
Analysis Of Heaney's Punishment Page 2
Analysis Of Heaney's Punishment Page 3
The above thumbnails are of reduced quality. To view the work in full quality, click download.

Question: "On the surface, Heaney's poems are very simple. This simplicity however is deceptive, for the poems are usually most subtle and complex." What do you think of this response to Heaney's poems?
Heaney's poetry may at first, initially seem simple, yet his poems do contain more complex underlying themes and ideas. Heaney has refined his poetry to such a simple state, such as in 'Punishment', Blackberry Picking' and Death of a Naturalist', that his poems are superficially simple, yet have complex, thought provoking ideas seeded deeper below.
This initial simplicity is seen in the poem 'Punishment', yet is deceptive, as the poem deals with many other complicated and sophisticated ideas in relation to human nature and anthropology.
The poem may seem simple at first such as;

"your brains exposed
and darkened combs
your muscles webbing
and all your numbered bones" (Stanza 9)

These lines indicated the straight forward almost scientific nature of the poem, through Heaneys choice of unemotive words. This simplicity is seen throughout the poem, where the reader initially could perceive the poem to solely be about the life, and appearance of a 'bog woman'. However at a deeper level, Heaney looks at the very human society functions, both in ancient and present times. This us summed up at the end of the poem;

"who would connive
in civilized outrage
yet understand the exact
and tribal, intimate revenge" (Stanza 11)

Heaney here, writes that he does not only feel empathy and sympathy towards the "little Adulteress", but is also able to detach himself from his emotions and look at her death as a function of an ancient tribal system. The role which the bog woman played in her society is further elaborated to the role in which she would have played in contemporary society;

"When your betraying sisters,
cauled in tar,
wept by the railings" (Stanza 10)

This comparison of the woman's sacrificial death in the past, and in modern Ireland in the present, is a concept which is far more complex than the poem initially portrays. Heaney recognizes that the death of the woman in the past was necessary to keep their society functioning which is seen in his choice of words "exact" "tribal" and "intimate" are the words used to describe the murder, which in no way convey a negative connotation. This is detached, anthropological view, is presented in a very simple manner through the use of shunt, concise words and stanzas as seen earlier. Thus the poem appear simple, however very serious, sophisticated ideas are embedded within
This underlying complexity of themes is also seen in the poem "Death of a Naturalist". This poem, again may seem like a simple descriptive passage at first, however this view is deceptive. Heaney recollects his youth, when he collected 'frog spawn' in jars and watched the tadpoles hatch into frogs. This is seen in

"I would fill jampotfuls of the jellied specks
and wait and watch until the
fattening dots burst into nimble swimming tadpoles"


You are currently seeing 50% of this paper.

You're seeing 525 words of 1049.

Keywords: punishment analysis seamus heaney, heaney analysis, heaney punishment, seamus heaney punishment, punishment heaney analysis

Similar essays

Emily Dickinson Notes

Emily Dickinson- born 12/10/1830 Amherst Massachusetts -Left school as teen to live reclusive life on family homestead where she wrote notebooks of poetry. -Work was published after death may 15, 1886. Now considered 1 of towering figues of American lit -Her paternal grandfather, Samuel Dickinson- founder of Amherst College. -Her father worked...

161 reviews
Emily Dickenson And The Theme Of Death

Emily Dickenson, an unconventional 19th century poet, used death as the theme for many of her poems. Dickenson's poems offer a creative and refreshingly different perspective on death and its effects on others. In Dickenson's poems, death is often personified, and is also assigned to personalities far different from the traditional "horror movie"...

165 reviews
"Gunpowder Plot" By Vernon Scannell

Write an account of a poem which deals with an unusual or unpleasant aspect of life. Show clearly how the poet uses such elements as effective words and vivid images to create something memorable. The poem "Gunpowder Plot" was interesting as its title holds three meanings. The author could have meant an allotment where gunpowder or firewor...

90 reviews
The Poetry Of William Cullen Bryant And Emily Dickinson: The Theme Of Death

Many poems are written about death. The two poets William Cullen Bryant and Emily Dickinson were very influential trancendental writers. Bryant writing Thanatopsis And Emily Dickinson's "Because I Could Not Stop for Death" are basically more alike then than they are similar for the fact that there views on Death are the same, but what happens to yo...

126 reviews
"A World Of Light And Dark"

Poetry- Essay 1 New Criticism "Let me not to the marriage of true minds/ Admit impediments...," begins Shakespeare in his "Sonnet 116". This work is a potent discourse on the nature of love, not only because of the passion which Shakespeare spills forth onto the page, but also because it takes a bold stance concerning the most mysterious of emotio...

74 reviews
Atsisiųsti šį darbą